I’m not sure what you’re referring to actually by “made it to Fosstodon”. Both mastodon.social and fosstodon would be running the same software, unless fosstodon are running some sort of fork which would make sense.
I was referring to how mastodon.social is by the largest mastodon instance (like it’s not even close) and is run by the mastodon group/company itself who have control over the software, app, joinmastodon.org web page etc. That’s getting pretty centralised.
Case in point, around May mastodon altered their mobile apps to set mastodon.social as the default server for creating a new account. Since then basically all new mastodon accounts have been only on mastodon.social. Now making the server selection process easier for newcomers makes a lot of sense, but it didn’t need to be done in a way that both highlighted and amplified the already notable centralisation. At the time a bunch of people got upset and pointed out alternatives. But mastodon the company didn’t say anything and of course there wasn’t anything anyone could do. And now, mastodon.social grows by about the same size of the next biggest english speaking mastodon instance every couple of months and no one likes to talk about it because they can’t do anything. By reasonable approximations, the fediverse is mastodon, and mastodon is becoming mastodon.social.
Numerically, by Monthly Active Users (MAUs) mastodon is ~85% of the fediverse, and mastodon.social is ~25% of all of mastodon, or, ~22% of all of the fediverse. (See fedidb)
Something like that happening with lemmy seems less likely, even far less likely, just because of the flatter power dynamics.
I’m not sure what you’re referring to actually by “made it to Fosstodon”. Both mastodon.social and fosstodon would be running the same software, unless fosstodon are running some sort of fork which would make sense.
I was referring to how mastodon.social is by the largest mastodon instance (like it’s not even close) and is run by the mastodon group/company itself who have control over the software, app, joinmastodon.org web page etc. That’s getting pretty centralised.
Case in point, around May mastodon altered their mobile apps to set mastodon.social as the default server for creating a new account. Since then basically all new mastodon accounts have been only on mastodon.social. Now making the server selection process easier for newcomers makes a lot of sense, but it didn’t need to be done in a way that both highlighted and amplified the already notable centralisation. At the time a bunch of people got upset and pointed out alternatives. But mastodon the company didn’t say anything and of course there wasn’t anything anyone could do. And now, mastodon.social grows by about the same size of the next biggest english speaking mastodon instance every couple of months and no one likes to talk about it because they can’t do anything. By reasonable approximations, the fediverse is mastodon, and mastodon is becoming mastodon.social.
Numerically, by Monthly Active Users (MAUs) mastodon is
~85%of the fediverse, and mastodon.social is~25%of all of mastodon, or,~22%of all of the fediverse. (See fedidb)Something like that happening with lemmy seems less likely, even far less likely, just because of the flatter power dynamics.