There’s value to both, but I understand the frustration. A big part of building a world without cars is developing an anti-car culture though, and memes are very effective at that.

This question came up often in the old /r/fuckcars and the response there was typically that discussion of solutions and activism made more sense in other communities like NotJustBikes and WalkableCities. I don’t know if those have corresponding federated communities yet though.

The name wasn’t a give away? You can join our https://slrpnk.net/c/urbanism community if you want.

The same issue is with any anti-something community and also on reddit. Eventually they turn into picture-of-text karma farms.

It’s really easy to unite people in negativity when being against something in common, but it’s a lot harder to unite them in being for any solution.

I dislike the idea of copying subreddits to here for that reason. The problems follow along too.

It might have been more useful on Reddit, because of the massive userbase, to shout out anti messages from the roof tops, hoping to sway some opinions, but without any suggestions for solutions it’s just rabble-rabble.

Imagine if the president said “look anti-car people, we hear you, what do you want?”

And it would still be “rabble rabble”, because the anti-car communies consist of people who want to: ban large SUVs and trucks, have more public transport, ride their bicycles, have more pedestrian streets, change the property zoning, change politics, etc.etc. and they don’t necessarily agree on what they want.